The Battlefield Where the Girls Say I Love You



That's just the thing: we will never tell you we love you. In fact, we're here only to hold hands across state lines and yell at the world. We're here to try to touch you across this chasm of flown things. Not even that. At most, I will teach you how to make a gin smoothie when there's nothing left in the house. Hannah can teach you several languages and what to do when your car breaks up with you. Thanks for coming out.

Thursday, August 30, 2007

sarcasm is the body's natural defense against stupid.

mark cox says that "irony (is) the intellectual posturing of a mind afraid of genuine tenderness," that irony and sentimentality are the downfalls of a writer who is not ready or willing to investigate and develop honest emotion.

i always felt that carolyn forche was too honest. reading her poems felt like staring directly into the sun for seasons, for decades. and, to a point, that remains true. if forche's work were my lover, it would be my natural inclination to sneak out in the middle of the night to meet up with an episode of "flight of the conchords" or a copy of "instyle" or, hell, a mix cd consisting only of akon and t.pain.

she is remarkable, all the same. in her introduction to the anthology, "against forgetting," she states that we are a society on the brink, that to hold political and personal poetry in mutually exclusive realms is irresponsible, that those who turn their backs to the stories of witness are those who lack compassion. it was synchronistic that i read this yesterday, on the anniversary of katrina.

so at times hannah and i seem flip (i mean, we're f-ing bloggers). and at other times, perhaps, we will seem too earnest. but anything written, i guess, is the translation of experience into form. forche writes that translation is "an attempt to mark, to change, to impress, but never to leave things as they are."

which brings me to the james taylor tribute i watched on ETV last night with my parents. i get through the dixie chicks covering something or other. i only seriously lose it when sting sings "you can close your eyes." i had made that ugly-claire-danes-in-my-so-called-life i'm-about-to-cry-face for, like, the previous hour. by this point, it's all over. but this is the truly embarrassing part. this is my karmic fate for making fun of john mayer and james blunt and the like: keith urban comes on stage. KEITH URBAN. and he performs "country road." sobbing. KEITH URBAN. the guy who sings, "take your bags but leave my sweater, cause we've got nothing left to weather."

so how is it that hannah and i make it through an entirely tragic summer without so much as a watering of the eyes, and yet...ETV. i guess it makes sense. we all have that artist or writer or musician who remains the soundtrack or backdrop or dialogue of our childhoods. that one band or singer who returns us to the backseat of our parents' car twenty years ago. who knows. keith urban. jesus.

oh, and owen wilson???!!! what is happening?

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

i AM sorry for being dismissive of the keith urban/j. taylor breakdown. i just thought, you know, something had happened happened. and now i know that something DID and even though it was ETV that happened, i'm totally here for you.

sheepish shoves, gentle shoulder punches and hasty back pats--h.

sallylynn said...

hannah and mames ~

the blog won't let me comment on hannah's post. so i'll leave a double dose of comments here.

1) keith urban? at the very least, it's not john mellencamp's chevy commercial song...so forgiveness and understanding are here for you (this, from the girl who listens to teddy thompson and cries and cries and cries...)

2) i love the poem, hannah.

3) does this mean you've actually finished moby dick? does it make me a terrible english major that i've never read even the first page, but still make jokes about the title? it does, i know.

Anonymous said...

no, no. don't give me too credit. i HAD to read it, living on the boat and all. there is that part though that always stumbles me where he goes on and on about the hull of the boat and the whale's attacking... never mind.

and can i admit that you girls are talking a different language altogether here? i'm pretty sure i've never actually heard keith urban or heard of teddy thompson.

sallylynn said...

trust me when i tell you that your life isn't incomplete without keith urban. although i would stand up for teddy thompson...